Jeff, what pre/adc and recorder are you going to be running for the second rig? I think that is important for people to give an educated opinion. He never said he was running the exact same equipment for the second rig except for the mics.
So here is my opinion. I would go with the Peluso's, and a modded UA5. That would be around $1200, but I suck at math when it comes to gear. Of course this opinion only is valid if you don't have a solid pre/adc lined up for this second rig(which sounds to me as if it is soon going to be your main rig).
If you do already have a second pre/adc that you are happy with, then you could do a whole hell of a lot with $1200. However you don't seem to me that you are the kind of guy that even wants to screw around with all the different patterns and configs. You just want to point and shoot, right? So that being said, I would go akg 480s with a pair of ck63 hyper caps, brand spankin new! If you do however feel that you want to mess around with all the different "geeky" techniques, I'd go peluso's with all of the caps. I think the most important thing here is that you end up with a good set of hypers. The places that you tape in, need them. I'm just sayin'.
Edit: Oh yeah, you can always use a set of my mics during all good for one of your rigs. I will be bringing the km140s, 414s and LSD2, heck I could even loan you my pair of C4s since you dig em so much. If of course I still have all of them by the time all good rolls around, thats like 2 and a half months.
Might be a different line up by then. Regardless you could use a pair of my mics, I'm sure I will still have at least two pairs