Here's my signal chain: DSM-6S/EL > PA-24NJ (+0 gain, 90hz roll-off) > Edirol R-09 (mic gain low, AGC off, low cut off, stereo ext mic, input volume set to "7").
I saw no red flashing light on the preamp, which I believe only kicks in at -3dB, and the deck averaged about -12 to -10db.
Here's the kicker...this was Tool, and it was absolutely the loudest bass I have ever heard at a concert. I was at the back of the floor in front of the soundboard and it was rattling my ribcage and jaw almost constantly (thank god for -20dB ear plugs).
I have taped a lot of shows at a lot of different venues, with a lot of loud, bass-heavy bands, and I've never had this problem before.
EDIT: Ok, looking at the EQ upon playback, it looks like a skateboard ramp...not good. I mean, it looks like I taped a normal rock show WITHOUT roll-off, but again, I'm positive I had it set to 90hz. That's the most aggressive roll-off setting that I have, what do I do in the future? And can this be fixed at all?