To avoid this, you could select about 1/2 the desired part and fade it out, then select the 2nd half and fade back in...
of course, the compression still sounds better, IMHO, though the volume tool still serves its purpose (it is great for those stealthed tapes where everything was too low b/c you couldn't check levels and ran soft to avoid clipping).
Yeah, but then you hear the fade-out/in between every song. Easier on the ears than a quick drop/jump in volume, but as you suggest - definitely not ideal.
agreed, I have tried messing w/ the volume but compression just sounds more natural and preserves the flow of the recording better IMHO. Fade in/out would be fine if you have the patience to do this, but the initial claps at the start of the fade will still be really loud, so if you plan to peak normalize afterward, you will still have a problem if you want the music to be the loudest thing on the recording.
Take care,
Ben