Michael.
You said you wanted to be happy the first time you buy. If that's the case then you should ask the questions here to get steered in the right direction, but you should use that as a basis for conducting your own research on Live Music Archive. Please PLEASE believe me. I've said this sooo many times to people and the newbs just don't get it. And there are so many people on this list that will tell you the same thing. Advice on this list is well intentioned, but it's also naturally biased to whatever the person that's doing the recommending likes. Lots of people love the Beyer MC930s and fluff them up...I do not like them much at all. YOU need to decide what sounds best to you, because different mics really do sound very different.
Trust your own ears too. You might be a newb, but you only have your own ears to listen to. For example, when I was a newb, I bought some mics and EVERYONE fluffed a specific preamp as being T-H-E preamp to match with these mics. I listened to the combo on Live Music Archive and I really didn't care all that much for the sound, but since I was a noob, I ended up reasoning that everyone else couldn't be wrong, so I bought the fluffed preamp and never liked it from Day One.
So, get a list of possibilities together and then go onto Live Music Archive and spend AT LEAST two hours listening to different samples. This is a major purchase and two hours is no time at all when you consider the amount of money you're considering spending.
Having said this...you really would do yourself a favor in looking at the yard sale before buying new. With the economy being so poor right now, the yard sale is chock FULL of great gear right now. In fact, there's some gear in the yard sale that you just never see there and its because of the combination of christmas season and the economy.
I'd even say that once you decide which mics/preamp combination you want, do an ISO (in search of) in the Yard Sale. More times than not, when someone posts an ISO, they are able to unearth some good condition used gear that meets the specifications of what they're searching for.
I hope this helps.
Steve