fwiw...
the OOP issues w/the R4 were with that particular unit, AFAIK. I spoke w/Edirol yesterday about it. they said it was probalby just a soldering miss-hap. it happens...
the R4 resamples on input, thats a fact.
but, who cares?
garrunteed, 99% of us have gear that resamples it on input (like the DAC in your CD player, or your stand alone DAC). My sony does it. My Philips deck did it. Most new CD/DVD players do it. Its marketed as a "high end" feature on many products. While its marketed as an "upsample", which it is doing.....it is resamping the original stream none the less.
yet..when your recorder does it..its taboo.
I understand its not desirable, but the reality is...you dont know or cant hear what your may or maynot be missing.
is this saying that resampling on input definately fucks up a nice incoming stable signal?
I dont know for sure. my guess would be no.