Taperssection.com

Gear / Technical Help => Microphones & Setup => Topic started by: heathen on September 04, 2018, 07:16:37 PM

Title: Has anyone tried the Windtech "Military High Density" windscreens?
Post by: heathen on September 04, 2018, 07:16:37 PM
In my search for good outdoor windscreens for my AT853s, I came across this page: http://www.windtech.tv/Small_Windscreens.php

The tiny stock screens for the AT853 are useless in any real outdoor wind (I tried them for the hell of it at Red Rocks and it was a joke).  They list the 10380 "Military High Density" screen for the AT853, and claim "This windscreen offers up to 20db of wind noise protection, depending the microphone being used, with virtually no affect on the microphone frequency response."  Has anyone tried this screen, or any of their other "Military High Density" screens?
Title: Re: Has anyone tried the Windtech "Military High Density" windscreens?
Post by: Gutbucket on September 05, 2018, 12:00:25 PM
Use a sufficiently phat windscreen.  Wind doesn't care how well-endowed your microphone may or may not be, only how wind-noise-sensitive it is.  I've never understood the standard paring of tiny windscreens to tiny microphones, except in on-talent applications where everything has to be small for visual reasons.  Tiny screens just don't trap sufficient dead-airspace to work well.  They are fine for omnis which already have limited sensitivity to wind, but for directional mics you need a good screen of sufficient size, irregardless of the size of the microphone.

These days, I use Shure A81-WS (B.A.S.) for my directional mics, including the miniature DPA 4098 supercards, which require a little foam insert (repurposed open-pore hair curler foams) to fit snugly into the big windscreen's microphone recess without gaps.  To outsiders it may seem ridiculous to mount such a large foam screen on such a tiny microphone, especially as the tiny built-in gooseneck-support of the 4098 is not strong enough to support the heft of the windscreen on it's own without sagging, but I've found that level of wind protection is what is required to sufficiently attenuate wind noise in my supercards without worries.  Alternate is using a "dead-critter" long-haired fur windjammer overcoat over a smaller foam screen which would otherwise be insufficient on its own, but I find it works better and prefer the simplicity of always using the same sufficiently-large, dual-layer foam, Big Ass Shures.

If going Windtech, I'd look to their "dual foam" designs similar to the BAS using a layer of denser tiny-pore outer foam surrounding the airy, open-pore center core foam which creates a dead-airspace around the microphone, even if it requires nesting a 2nd small windscreen inside it in order to fit the diameter of the 853's.
Title: Re: Has anyone tried the Windtech "Military High Density" windscreens?
Post by: rocksuitcase on September 05, 2018, 01:26:50 PM
heathen, we use the Windtech BG1 on our AKG ck68's; it is excellent and seems to be similar but not the same material; they call this their "high Wind/ENG" series
http://www.windtech.tv/Shotgun_Windscreens.php

Would recommend to a friend       :)
Title: Re: Has anyone tried the Windtech "Military High Density" windscreens?
Post by: IMPigpen on September 05, 2018, 02:41:19 PM
I do the same as Gutbucket for my Naiant X-Rs outdoors, well not using the BAS.  For outdoors I use a pair of BAS with my Neumann 184s and I nest the Naiant windscreen inside a larger windscreen (have to check the model) that I use for the Neumanns indoors.  This past weekend I was at a venue right on Plymouth Harbor and there was a steady wind most of the night and had no issues.
Title: Re: Has anyone tried the Windtech "Military High Density" windscreens?
Post by: heathen on September 05, 2018, 03:08:51 PM
For one of the recent Phish shows I actually used the stock AT853 windscreens and put the AT8136 windscreens over those.  It worked that night, but they didn't fit all that snug and I could imagine a strong wind blowing them off.  It wasn't really windy at all that night, so I'm not even sure how much wind protection my half-ass solution would offer.  Hence my search for windscreens more specific to the AT853.
Title: Re: Has anyone tried the Windtech "Military High Density" windscreens?
Post by: noahbickart on September 05, 2018, 11:14:30 PM
If there are movo’s for your microphones, I highly recommend them.

They work and are very inexpensive.
Title: Re: Has anyone tried the Windtech "Military High Density" windscreens?
Post by: heathen on September 05, 2018, 11:17:04 PM
If there are movo’s for your microphones, I highly recommend them.

They work and are very inexpensive.

I'd be shocked if there's Movos small enough for the AT853s but it wouldn't hurt to check.  The AT853s would crumple under the weight of the Movos I've seen "in the wild."

Edit: I didn't realize Movo has such a wide variety of windscreen options.  They have a small furry lavalier windscreen that may be perfect.  Thanks for the tip Noah!
Title: Re: Has anyone tried the Windtech "Military High Density" windscreens?
Post by: Limit35 on September 06, 2018, 12:28:54 AM

I agree with the BAS screens, I have recorded in some pretty good wind with them. For AT853 hypers, I have run the AT8153 windscreens inside dynamic mic style screens from the local music shop with no problems. Shure screens are really worth the money IMHO. I was put off by the price but after having ruined recordings I realized why take all this gear out with me if I can't guarantee myself a good result.
Title: Re: Has anyone tried the Windtech "Military High Density" windscreens?
Post by: jcable77 on September 06, 2018, 04:13:24 AM
Movo ws10 furry windscreens i use on Naiant x-r’s work great. Might be the same size you need.
https://www.movophoto.com/products/movo-ws10n-universal-furry-outdoor-microphone-windscreen-lavalier
Title: Re: Has anyone tried the Windtech "Military High Density" windscreens?
Post by: heathen on September 06, 2018, 08:16:43 AM
Movo ws10 furry windscreens i use on Naiant x-r’s work great. Might be the same size you need.
https://www.movophoto.com/products/movo-ws10n-universal-furry-outdoor-microphone-windscreen-lavalier

I think their WS-RD 12 mm lav windscreen might actually be perfect for the AT853: https://www.movophoto.com/collections/microphone-accessories/products/movo-ws-rd-furry-lavalier-microphone-windscreens-2-pack-8mm-10mm-12mm?variant=10275510222892
Title: Re: Has anyone tried the Windtech "Military High Density" windscreens?
Post by: Perry on September 24, 2018, 04:19:50 PM
I just started using a layered approach, seems to work well. I put a Movo ballistic nylon screen https://www.movophoto.com/products/movo-wstt50-premium-quality-ballistic-nylon-windscreen-shotgun (https://www.movophoto.com/products/movo-wstt50-premium-quality-ballistic-nylon-windscreen-shotgun) over a Shure locking screen https://www.amazon.com/Shure-RK183WS-Black-Snap-Fit-Windscreens/dp/B003B1IPSE (https://www.amazon.com/Shure-RK183WS-Black-Snap-Fit-Windscreens/dp/B003B1IPSE) If I use the Shapeways 853 DIN mount, the Movo screens look like they're pointing up. They fit awkwardly but they work well.