Science invalidates its self frequently enough that it keeps me as the skeptic (and I'm referring to a far larger picture than just audio).
The only claim that I made was that allot of people have bought this kit for use with flea weight amps, have built it, and enjoy it and rave about it. Immediately people put up their guards, most without hearing them, or even reading a single review.
Amongst a group of hardcore audio enthusiasts, you will not find a single dissenter in that 50 page thread.
You don't have to mount them outside the cabinet to enjoy them. Dozens and dozens of people, hundreds (I don't know how many kits he's sold), have assembled it, and found audio bliss despite the bad science malarkey claim behind it.
These people that I've referred to are not easily fooled, as they've been playing this audio game for many decades, each, not a cumulative sum of time; between our team members, we have 50 years experience. Not.
The science of audio has gotten better on a relatively miniscule basis, compared to the time spent, the time that they've had to improve it, and, from where they started with modern electronics. Yes we have wonderful t-amps, we have ipods, and bluetooth headhphones, and wonderful cellphones that we can text with while driving, and in-dash GPS for the terminally lost. We have ipod docks on just about everything. I'm playing mine from my refrigerator right now, and loving it (I don't own an ipod, just saying).WE have companies that put out the ultimate amplifier each tme they reinvent it, because they know someone will need that improved amp - marketing ploys abundant, all based in our scientific teams deep commitment to improving your audio.
But, even with all the improvements, speakers still have cones, frames, and coils, just like they did 80 years ago. Hell, even some of the finest electrostat speaker are 55 years old, and are more desired than their modern counterparts.
The old guys set us up with the bomb. The science that followed the old guys has barely followed them; the changes, not that drastic.