Gear / Technical Help > Post-Processing, Computer / Streaming / Internet Devices & Related Activity

Fixing a once off talker. Ideas?

(1/4) > >>

shadowfax1007:
I've got an old recording of mine which overall I love - except for one track which almost ruins the listening experience for me.
At the 3:14 mark you here a drunk girl talking nearby to me, picked up strongly on the right channel.

I've experimented several times over the years with various audio tools, but I've never really been able to reduce it in a way that doesn't harm the experience too much. I'm kind of hoping some more seasoned editing veterans might be able to have a quick look at this one and make some suggestions for me? Please.
Alternatively I've got RX10 if people have settings/tools to suggest trying.

I've posted a link to the MP3 of the track itself, but I have the whole gig in it's original WAV format if the edit is required overall.


https://we.tl/t-It3luggwy4

Thanks!

Gordon:
Look at it in RX and figure out what her voice looks like (easy to spot).  Use the brush tool or lasso then spectral repair attenuate.  This was a quick attempt to tone it down.  It could be done better but you get the idea....


https://we.tl/t-SizfXMKKCb

breakonthru:
Its REALLY hard to get conversation out of a recording as it’s not sharp and sudden and it’s in the same frequency range as the music

When it’s hard on one channel the first thing I do is subtly swap channels via long fades. The image will collapse into mono and be noticeable on headphones but sometimes not noticeable at all when played back on speakers

Perhaps some combination of the above, where at first you try to reduce it on the one channel as much as possible, and then swap the channels as little as possible to try to maintain a little bit of image, and use the slight channel swap to partially cover up the manual work you did to remove the tower, which is not without consequences to the rest of the recording

nassau73:

--- Quote from: Gordon on April 27, 2024, 09:37:10 AM ---Look at it in RX and figure out what her voice looks like (easy to spot).  Use the brush tool or lasso then spectral repair attenuate.  This was a quick attempt to tone it down.  It could be done better but you get the idea....

--- End quote ---

True. Work in the RX Spectrogram View. The voice of the "talker" will be viewable as concentric lines in the area where they are talking.

This is a process I follow when I'm willing to be truly anal about getting rid of the talking. It's very time consuming so judge what you are willing to commit. I've been going back to some of my old 24 bit files and "fixing" ones that I want to listen to without the talking and screaming. This is also the process I follow when the talking is interfering with the music or vocals. If I want to bring down crowd noise between songs - that's different.

Remember that the loudest part of the talker will be closer to the bottom of your view.

That in mind, once I locate the the concentric lines of the talker, I go to the bottom of the display and SELECT a small area using the BOX SELECT TOOL that's the rightmost tool in the icons.

Then I use the magnifying glass icon that has the dotted lines around it. This magnifies everything so that now it's easy to start highlighting individual lines of the talker. I use the paintbrush tool set to a size that allows me to select the lines of the talker without affecting the surrounding areas. I start at the bottom and many times have to select every other line rather than the lines next to each other.

Once those are highlighted, I use the harmonic tool to select the harmonics out of range of the smaller selection that I'm viewing. Now attenuate or delete in spectral repair.Then I do the rinse and repeat thing - go back to what I missed the first time and do it again.

After I did this for awhile, I learned that I could see the talker lines in the middle of a vocal or interfering with the music so it's possible to really clean things up.

On recordings that I want to listen to and have egregious talker intrusions and am willing to spend the time - this has been working for me. My computer doesn't have the resources to split stems, etc.

Good luck if you try this.

robgronotte:
If the talk isn't over any singing, Ultimate Vocal Remover 5 is amazing, you can download for free online. I've used it so much in the last year that I consider myself an expert.

I would be happy to work on it. Would be great to let people hear the before and after.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page