OK folks, I was able to run a comp last night and here are the samples.
I was going to make it a poll, but I couldn't figure out an easy way to do it with 3 samples of 2 songs in 16 and 24 bit so feel free to make comments and guesses in any follow up posts.
The mics were beyerdynamic MC803. Mics were oriented a little higher than I wanted, but I got there late and decided to relax in the balcony. Still, they were in a pretty good position overall. They were run approximately DINa (maybe not quite, but close).
Cables (Audio Magic X-Streams) run into the Sonosax SX-M2 and then split. One side went line in to the SD 744t at 24bit/192kHz. The other side went line in to the Korg MR-1000 at 1bit/5.6mHz in DFF format.
Taking Freelunch's suggestion, I've prepared 3 samples each of two songs from the first set and processed them as follows:
The SD file was:
resampled to 24/48 in Wavelab for the 24 bit version.
resampled and dithered with UV22HR to 16/44 for the 16 bit version.
The Korg file was:
rendered to 24/192 in Audiogate, then
resampled to 24/48 in Wavelab for the 24 bit version.
resampled and dithered with UV22HR to 16/44 for the 16 bit version.
I also rendered two Korg files straight from 5.6mhz DFF to 24/48 and 16/44 respectively by using the conversion within Audiogate.
So the choices for each song are:
Korg Audiogate conversion
Korg dithered (and resampled for 16 bit)
SD dithered (and resampled for 16 bit)
I have taken the same 1:00/1:20 from each song for each version, but I have hand modified each of them slightly so they do NOT start at exactly the same sample (mainly because this would aid in identifying the Korg sources since there are two of them).
I have also shuffled them for the 24 bit versions, so what is "source A" in the 16 bit is not necessarily the same source in the 24 bit.
Yadda yadda yadda. Enough talk. Here are the samples. I'll leave them up for a few days, or until interest wanes, and then I'll post the key.
16 bit is here:
http://www.bigpurpledog.com/audio/korg_vs_744_16bit.zip24 bit wouldn't upload to my website for some reason, so it will only be available for a limited time. It's here:
http://www.yousendit.com/download/bWJxcXluQzNWRDgwTVE9PQHopefully this is all fairly clear.