Quote from: dlh on October 25, 2013, 09:16:00 AM
Best thread here in a long time. Reassures me that there are people who still trust science.
Thanks to Jon and Gutbucket.
Made me think of "If the facts don't conform to the theory, they must be disposed of." 
Dave
Wow, haven't looked at this thread in a while.
So, one take away from everything I read is a consensus that any quality of audio observed through human sensory perception that can not be proven in physical, quantitative, scientific terms is invalid. Problem is that science cannot explain why a musical note in the same key, at the same pitch and loudness, looking identical on a scope or waveform measurement device, can be distinguished by it's timbre. Now I agree human sensory perception is not always great, for example the singer who thinks she has perfect pitch but to outside listeners it sounds like a cat being beaten. Compare to Victor Wooten who is well known for having perfect ptich perception and can hear the smallest tick of a note towards being flat or sharp. Science cannot account for this, but we know it's true.