It truly depends on the mastering engineer more than anything else.
Don't assume that analog is "purer" - this is a falsehood. This goes 100 fold for vinyl, where there is the RIAA curve which is compensated for, adding at least another stage of electronics to color the sound.
Don't believe that preamps and amps won't color sound. Their goal, usually, is to not, but all do it, for good or ill.
Don't especially believe that an analog motor won't severely distort the sound.
This is where (all) turntables fail miserably compared to digital. (Yes, even the one that Singer Sound has for $25k)
CD at 44.1 can reproduce 22kHz sounds without distortion. When I write none, I mean that the waveform is sampled twice as fast as the wave form is and none is none. All else is "smoke and mirries", folks... yes, I am opinionated, but you'd have to prove Dr. Nyquist wrong, if you can.
The pictures show a faster waveform than the sample rate! (as in a 20kHz sound being sampled at 16kHz)
The picture also displays a wave making a move that cannot exist as it folds back on itself,which requires time to move backwards.
I doubt that you, as a human male, can hear above about 16kHz, although you will be able sense space and other qualities over 16kHz.
This is the way it is, if you doubt me, please get a hearing test!
There are a very few who can hear 18kHz, and virtually none who can hear 19kHz.
Analog is decidedly different, overall, than digital. Two flavors, take your choice.
Overall, digital will be much more accurate for many reasons. The least being that all of the R&D bucks for the last 20-30 years have gone to it, and not analog.
Many analog vendors sadly compensate for lack of product advance by lying about their technologies.
"We make our cartridges from REAL WOOD for a more ORGANIC sound!"
Freakin' Puh-lease! Is it not obvious that that is technically-retarded logic?
Again, my rant is not to try to tell you what to enjoy.
Please listen first and buy what you like best!
However, vinyl is not a panacea. In fact from a technology standpoint, vinyl was abandonded for very many valid reasons.