I've been with Servage for 10 years, no major issues. Occasional short downtimes have been the worst. But for a site that only gets 200 visitors on a busy day, it's fine.
Multiple hackings? Keep your installation of WordPress up to date, and use strong passwords. Nothing different needed than with other hosts.
HD failure? If you aren't backing up your site, you aren't doing it right.
Also remember that they are a very high volume host. Unhappy customers post reviews more than happy, this gets magnified for a large provider.
Cost vs. risk. Your choice.